Open energy system databases

From KYNNpedia
Revision as of 00:02, 13 January 2024 by imported>BD2412 (clean up spacing around commas and other punctuation fixes, replaced: ,n → , n)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
For a list of models that utilize open energy system data, see Open energy system models.

Open energy system database projects employ open data methods to collect, clean, and republish energy-related datasets for open use. The resulting information is then available, given a suitable open license, for statistical analysis and for building numerical energy system models, including open energy system models. Permissive licenses like Creative Commons CC0 and CC BY are preferred, but some projects will house data made public under market transparency regulations and carrying unqualified copyright.

The databases themselves may furnish information on national power plant fleets, renewable generation assets, transmission networks, time series for electricity loads, dispatch, spot prices, and cross-border trades, weather information, and similar. They may also offer other energy statistics including fossil fuel imports and exports, gas, oil, and coal prices, emissions certificate prices, and information on energy efficiency costs and benefits.

Much of the data is sourced from official or semi-official agencies, including national statistics offices, transmission system operators, and electricity market operators. Data is also crowdsourced using public wikis and public upload facilities.<ref name="arderne-etal-2020"> Arderne, C; Zorn, C; Nicolas, C; Koks, EE (15 January 2020). "Predictive mapping of the global power system using open data" (PDF). Scientific Data. 7 (1): 19. Bibcode:2020NatSD...7...19A. doi:10.1038/s41597-019-0347-4. ISSN 2052-4463. PMC 6962213. PMID 31941897. Retrieved 4 March 2021. </ref> Projects usually also maintain a strict record of the provenance and version histories of the datasets they hold. Some projects, as part of their mandate, also try to persuade primary data providers to release their data under more liberal licensing conditions.<ref group="lower-alpha"></ref>

Two drivers favor the establishment of such databases. The first is a wish to reduce the duplication of effort that accompanies each new analytical project as it assembles and processes the data that it needs from primary sources. And the second is an increasing desire to make public policy energy models more transparent to improve their acceptance by policymakers and the public.<ref name="acatech-etal-2016"> acatech; Lepoldina; Akademienunion, eds. (2016). Consulting with energy scenarios: requirements for scientific policy advice (PDF). Berlin, Germany: acatech — National Academy of Science and Engineering. ISBN 978-3-8047-3550-7. Archived from the original (PDF) on 21 December 2016. Retrieved 19 December 2016.</ref> Better transparency dictates the use of open information, able to be accessed and scrutinized by third-parties, in addition to releasing the source code for the models in question.<ref name="decarolis-etal-2012"/>


General considerations

Background

In the mid-1990s, energy models used structured text files for data interchange but efforts were being made to migrate to relational database management systems for data processing.<ref name="groscurth-1995-075bf0"> Groscurth, Helmuth-M (1 July 1995). "Design and management of energy databases". Energy Sources. 17 (4): 445–457. doi:10.1080/00908319508946093. ISSN 0090-8312. </ref> These early efforts however remained local to a project and did not involve online publishing or open data principles.

The first energy information portal to go live was OpenEI in late 2009, followed by reegle in 2011.

A 2012 paper marks the first scientific publication to advocate the crowdsourcing of energy data.<ref name="bazilian-etal-2012"> Bazilian, Morgan; Rice, Andrew; Rotich, Juliana; Howells, Mark; DeCarolis, Joseph; Macmillan, Stuart; Brooks, Cameron; Bauer, Florian; Liebreich, Michael (2012). "Open source software and crowdsourcing for energy analysis" (PDF). Energy Policy. 49: 149–153. doi:10.1016/j.enpol.2012.06.032. Retrieved 17 June 2016. </ref> The 2012 PhD thesis by Chris Davis also discusses the crowdsourcing of energy data in some depth.<ref name="davis-2012"/> A 2016 thesis surveyed the spatial (GIS) information requirements for energy planning and finds that most types of data, with the exception of energy expenditure data, are available but nonetheless remain scattered and poorly coordinated.<ref name="berndtsson-2016-msc"> Berndtsson, Carl (2016). Open geospatial data for energy planning (MSc). Stockholm, Sweden: KTH School of Industrial Engineering and Management. Retrieved 7 March 2017. </ref>

In terms of open data, a 2017 paper concludes that energy research has lagged behind other fields, most notably physics, biotechnology, and medicine.<ref name="pfenninger-etal-2017"> Pfenninger, Stefan; DeCarolis, Joseph; Hirth, Lion; Quoilin, Sylvain; Staffell, Iain (February 2017). "The importance of open data and software: is energy research lagging behind?". Energy Policy. 101: 211–215. doi:10.1016/j.enpol.2016.11.046. hdl:10044/1/56796. ISSN 0301-4215. Open access icon </ref>: 213–214  The paper also lists the benefits of open data and open models and discusses the reasons that many projects nonetheless remain closed.<ref name="pfenninger-etal-2017"/>: 211–213  A one-page opinion piece from 2017 advances the case for using open energy data and modeling to build public trust in policy analysis. The article also argues that scientific journals have a responsibility to require that data and code be submitted alongside text for peer review.<ref name="pfenninger-2017"> Pfenninger, Stefan (23 February 2017). "Energy scientists must show their workings" (PDF). Nature News. 542 (7642): 393. Bibcode:2017Natur.542..393P. doi:10.1038/542393a. PMID 28230147. Retrieved 26 February 2017. </ref>

Database design

Data models are central to the design and organization of databases. Open energy database projects generally try to develop and adhere to well resolved data models, using de facto and published standards where applicable. Some projects attempt to coordinate their data models in order to harmonize their data and improve its utility. Defining and maintaining suitable metadata is also a key issue. The life-cycle management of data includes, but is not limited to, the use of version control to track the provenance of incoming and cleansed data. Some sites allow users to comment on and rate individual datasets.

Dataset copyright and database rights

Issues surrounding copyright remain at the forefront with regard to open energy data. As noted, most energy datasets are collated and published by official or semi-official sources. But many of the publicly available energy datasets carry no license, limiting their reuse in numerical and statistical models, open or otherwise. Copyright protected material cannot lawfully be circulated, nor can it be modified and republished.

Measures to enforce market transparency have not helped much because the associated information is again not licensed to enable modification and republication. Transparency measures include the 2013 European energy market transparency regulation 543/2013.<ref name="ec-regulation-543-2013"> European Commission (15 June 2013). "Commission Regulation (EU) No 543/2013 of 14 June 2013 on submission and publication of data in electricity markets and amending Annex I to Regulation (EC) No 714/2009 of the European Parliament and of the Council". Official Journal of the European Union. L 163: 1–12. Retrieved 1 December 2016. </ref> Indeed, 543/2013 "is only an obligation to publish, not an obligation to license".<ref name="boecker-2016"/>: slide 14  Notwithstanding, 543/2013 does enable downloaded data to be computer processed with legal certainty.<ref name="jaeger-2017"/>: 5 

Energy databases with hardware located with the European Union are protected under a general database law, irrespective of the legal status of the information they hold.<ref name="boecker-2016"> Boecker, Lina (21 November 2016). Energy databases: protection and licensing (PDF). Berlin, Germany: JBB Rechtsanwaelte. </ref> Database rights not waived by public sector providers significantly restrict the amount of data a user can lawfully access.

A December 2017 submission by energy researchers in Germany and elsewhere highlighted a number of concerns over the re-use of public sector information within the Europe Union.<ref name="morrison-etal-2017"> Morrison, Robbie; Brown, Tom; De Felice, Matteo (10 December 2017). Submission on the re-use of public sector information: with an emphasis on energy system datasets — Release 09 (PDF). Berlin, Germany. Retrieved 13 December 2017.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link) Open access icon </ref> The submission drew heavily on a recent legal opinion covering electricity data.<ref name="jaeger-2017"> Jaeger, Till (24 July 2017). Legal aspects of European electricity data — Legal opinion (PDF). Berlin, Germany: JBB Rechtsanwälte. Retrieved 13 October 2017. </ref>

Energy statistics

National and international energy statistics are published regularly by governments and international agencies, such as the IEA.<ref name="iea-2016"> Key world energy statistics (PDF). Paris, France: International Energy Agency (IEA). 2016. Retrieved 15 December 2016. </ref> In 2016 the United Nations issued guidelines for energy statistics.<ref name="ires-2016"> International Recommendations for Energy Statistics (IRES) — ST/ESA/STAT/SER.M/93 (PDF). New York, NY, USA: Statistics Division, Department of Economic and Social Affairs, United Nations. 2016. ISBN 978-92-1-056520-2. Retrieved 17 December 2016. Annotated as final edited version prior to typesetting. Also covers energy-related greenhouse gas emissions accounting. </ref> While the definitions and sectoral breakdowns are useful when defining models, the information provided is rarely in sufficient detail to enable its use in high-resolution energy system models.<ref name="pfenninger-etal-2017"/>: 213 

Published standards

There are few published standards covering the collection and structuring of high-resolution energy system data. The IEC Common Information Model (CIM) defines data exchange protocols for low and high voltage electricity networks.

Non-open data

Although this page is about genuinely open data, some important databases remain closed.

Data collected by the International Energy Agency (IEA) is widely quoted in policy studies but remains nonetheless paywalled. Researchers at Oxford University have called for this situation to change.<ref name="roser-and-ritchie-2021"> Roser, Max; Ritchie, Hannah (7 October 2021). "The International Energy Agency publishes the detailed, global energy data we all need, but its funders force it behind paywalls: let's ask them to change it". Our World in Data. Oxford, United Kingdom. Retrieved 5 November 2021. </ref>

Open energy system database projects

Energy system models are data intensive and normally require detailed information from a number of sources. Dedicated projects to collect, collate, document, and republish energy system datasets have arisen to service this need. Most database projects prefer open data, issued under free licenses, but some will accept datasets with proprietary licenses in the absence of other options.

The OpenStreetMap project, which uses the Open Database License (ODbL), contains geographic information about energy system components, including transmission lines.<ref name="osm-ongoing"> "Power — OpenStreetMap Wiki". OpenStreetMap. Retrieved 6 January 2019. </ref> Wikimedia projects such as Wikidata and Wikipedia have a growing set of information related to national energy systems, such as descriptions of individual power stations.<ref name="davis-2012"/>: 156–159 

The following table summarizes projects that specifically publish open energy system data. Some are general repositories while others (for instance, oedb) are designed to interact with open energy system models in real-time.

Open energy system database projects
Project Host License Access Data formats Scope/type
CCG starter datasets Climate Compatible Growth and OpTIMUS projects CC0 1.0 Zenodo archive various focus on non‑western countries
Energy Research Data Portal for South Africa University of Cape Town CC BY 4.0 preferred website, API various countries in Africa
energydata.info World Bank Group CC BY 4.0 preferred website various includes visualization and analytics
Enipedia Delft University of Technology ODbL semantic wiki, LOD JSON global materials and energy
Open Energy Platform
dataset-specific website, API CSV, REST, PostgreSQL model-oriented
Open Data Energy Networks French RTE and partners CC BY 2.0 compatible website, API JSON, CSV, XLS, SHP French energy system
Open Data Portal UK Power Networks CC BY 4.0 and OGL website, API CSV, JSON, XML, SHP, Keyhole Markup Language, GeoJSON GB Distribution Network Operator
Open Power System Data
dataset-specific website, API CSV, JSON, XLSX, SQLite western European power system
OpenEI US Department of Energy CC0, open licenses semantic wiki, LOD CSV US focus
OpenGridMap Technical University of Munich CC BY 3.0 IGO website CSV, XML, CIM electricity grid data worldwide
Power Explorer World Resources Institute CC BY 4.0 preferred website various global power data
PowerGenome — CC BY 4.0 GitHub, Zenodo CSV US electricity system
reegle
— website, LOD — clean energy
Renewables.ninja
CC BY-NC 4.0 website, API CSV, JSON worldwide hourly PV and wind
SMARD German BNetzA CC BY 4.0 website CSV, XLS, XML, PDF DE, AT, and LU electricity systems
  • Access refers to the protocols offered for accessing the database, both manual and programmatic.
  • Data formats are the formats under which datasets and metadata may be downloaded. The PDF format is for inspection and not machine processing.

Three of the projects listed work with linked open data (LOD), a method of publishing structured data on the web so that it can be networked and subject to semantic queries. The overarching concept is termed the semantic web. Technically, such projects support RESTful APIs, RDF, and the SPARQL query language. A 2012 paper reviews the use of LOD in the renewable energy domain.<ref name="abanda-and-tah-2012"> Abanda, Henry; Tah, Joseph (2012). Linked data in renewable energy domain. CiteSeerX 10.1.1.690.9922. </ref>

Climate Compatible Growth starter datasets

Project Climate Compatible Growth
Host Climate Compatible Gowth and OpTIMUS projects
Status active
Scope/type numerous countries
Data license CC0 1.0
Website see text

The Climate Compatible Growth (CCG) programme provides starter kits for the following 69 countries: Algeria, Angola, Argentina, Benin, Botswana, Bolivia, Brazil, Burkina Faso, Burundi, Cambodia, Cameroon, Central African Republic, Chad, Chile, Colombia, Côte d'Ivoire, Democratic Republic of Congo, Djibouti, Ecuador, Egypt, Equatorial Guinea, Eritrea, Eswatini, Ethiopia, Gabon, Gambia, Ghana, Guinea, Guinea-Bissau, Indonesia, Kenya, Laos, Lesotho, Liberia, Libya, Malawi, Malaysia, Mali, Mauritania, Morocco, Mozambique, Myanmar, Namibia, Niger, Nigeria, Papua New Guinea, Paraguay, Peru, Philippines, Republic of Congo, Republic of Korea, Rwanda, Senegal, Sierra Leone, Somalia, South Africa, South Sudan, Sudan, Taiwan, Tanzania, Thailand, Togo, Tunisia, Uganda, Uruguay, Venezuela, Viet Nam, Zambia, and Zimbabwe.

The datasets are hosted on the Zenodo science archive site, visit that site and search for "ccg starter kit".

Energy Research Data Portal for South Africa

Project Energy Research Data Portal for South Africa
Host University of Cape Town
Status active
Scope/type countries in Africa
Data license CC BY 4.0 preferred
Website energydata.uct.ac.za

The Energy Research Data Portal for South Africa is being developed by the Energy Research Centre, University of Cape Town, Cape Town, South Africa. Coverage includes South Africa and certain other African countries where the Centre undertakes projects.<ref group="lower-alpha">The energydata.info project also holds datasets for African countries.</ref> The website uses the CKAN open source data portal software. A number of data formats are supported, including CSV and XLSX. The site also offers an API for automated downloads. As of March 2017, the portal contained 65 datasets.

energydata.info

Project energydata.org
Host World Bank Group
Status active
Scope/type includes visualization and analytics
Code license app-specific
Data license CC BY 4.0 preferred
Website energydata.info
Repository github.com/energy-data

The energydata.info project from the World Bank Group, Washington, DC, USA is an energy database portal designed to support national development by improving public access to energy information.<ref name="energydata-info-website"> "Welcome — Energy Data". energydata.info. New York, USA. Retrieved 17 January 2017. </ref> As well as sharing data, the platform also offers tools to visualize and analyze energy data. Although the World Bank Group has made available a number of dataset and apps, external users and organizations are encouraged to contribute. The concepts of open data and open source development are central to the project. energydata.info uses its own fork of the CKAN open source data portal as its web-based platform. The Creative Commons CC BY 4.0 license is preferred for data but other open licenses can be deployed. Users are also bound by the terms of use for the site.<ref name="energydata-info-terms-of-use"> "Energy Data — Terms of use". energydata.info. New York, USA. Retrieved 17 January 2017. </ref>

As of January 2017, the database held 131 datasets, the great majority related to developing countries. The datasets are tagged and can be easily filtered. A number of download formats, including GIS files, are supported: CSV, XLS, XLSX, ArcGIS, Esri, GeoJSON, KML, and SHP. Some datasets are also offered as HTML. Again, as of January 2017, four apps are available. Some are web-based and run from a browser.

Enipedia

Project Enipedia
Host Delft University of Technology
Status inactive
Scope/type global materials and energy
Data license ODbL
Wiki enipedia.tudelft.nl

The semantic wiki-site and database Enipedia lists energy systems data worldwide.<ref name="davis-2012">Davis, Chris (2012). Making Sense Of Open Data (PDF) (PhD). Delft, The Netherlands: Delft University of Technology. Archived from the original on 21 February 2015. Retrieved 21 July 2016.{{cite thesis}}: CS1 maint: unfit URL (link) Chapter 9 discusses in depth the initial development of Enipedia.</ref><ref name="enipedia-website">Davis, Chris; Chmieliauskas, Alfredas; Dijkema, Gerard; Nikolic, Igor. "Enipedia". Delft, The Netherlands: Energy and Industry group, Faculty of Technology, Policy and Management, TU Delft. Archived from the original on 10 June 2014. Retrieved 7 October 2016.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: unfit URL (link)</ref> Enipedia is maintained by the Energy and Industry Group, Faculty of Technology, Policy and Management, Delft University of Technology, Delft, the Netherlands. A key tenet of Enipedia is that data displayed on the wiki is not trapped within the wiki, but can be extracted via SPARQL queries and used to populate new tools. Any programming environment that can download content from a URL can be used to obtain data.<ref name="enipedia-architecture"> "Enipedia:About — Architicture". Archived from the original on 1 August 2011. Retrieved 21 July 2016.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: unfit URL (link) </ref> Enipedia went live in March 2011, judging by traffic figures quoted by Davis.<ref name="davis-2012"/>: 185  : fig 9.17 

A 2010 study describes how community driven data collection, processing, curation, and sharing is revolutionizing the data needs of industrial ecology and energy system analysis.<ref name="davis-etal-2010"> Davis, Chris; Nikolic, Igor; Dijkema, Gerard PJ (October 2010). "Industrial ecology 2.0". Journal of Industrial Ecology. 14 (5): 707–726, October 2010 [1]. doi:10.1111/j.1530-9290.2010.00281.x. S2CID 154914379. </ref> A 2012 chapter introduces a system of systems engineering (SoSE) perspective and outlines how agent-based models and crowdsourced data can contribute to the solving of global issues.[citation needed]

As of April 2019, the site has gone offline pending a move to the <syntaxhighlight lang="text" class="" id="" style="" inline="1">enipedia.org</syntaxhighlight> domain.

Open Energy Platform

Project Open Energy Platform
Host
Status active
Scope/type model-oriented
Data license dataset-specific
Website openenergy-platform.org

The Open Energy Platform (OEP) is a collaborative versioned dataset repository for storing open energy system model datasets. A dataset is presumed to be in the form of a database table, together with metadata. Registered users can upload and download datasets manually using a web-interface or programmatically via an API using HTTP POST calls. Uploaded datasets are screened for integrity using deterministic rules and then subject to confirmation by a moderator. The use of versioning means that any prior state of the database can be accessed (as recommended in this 2012 paper).<ref name="decarolis-etal-2012">DeCarolis, Joseph F; Hunter, Kevin; Sreepathi, Sarat (2012). "The case for repeatable analysis with energy economy optimization models" (PDF). Energy Economics. 34 (6): 1845–1853. arXiv:2001.10858. doi:10.1016/j.eneco.2012.07.004. S2CID 59143900. Archived from the original (PDF) on 19 April 2016. Retrieved 8 July 2016.</ref> Hence, the repository is specifically designed to interoperate with energy system models. The backend is a PostgreSQL object-relational database under subversion version control. Open-data licenses are specific to each dataset. Unlike other database projects, users can download the current version (the public tables) of the entire PostgreSQL database or any previous version. The development is being led by a cross-project community.<ref name="huelk-2023"> Hülk, Ludwig (9 October 2023). The OEFamily and the OpenEnergyPlatform (OEP): a framework for research data management and a community database for energy data. Berlin, Germany: Reiner Lemoine Institut. doi:10.5281/zenodo.8421265. Retrieved 9 October 2023. DOI resolves to latest version. Open access icon </ref>

Open Data Energy Networks

Project Open Data Energy Networks
Host Réseau de Transport d'Électricité (RTE) and others
Status active
Scope/type French energy system
Data license Licence Ouverte (CC BY 2.0 compatible)<ref name="licence-ouverte"/>
Metadata French and English
Website opendata.reseaux-energies.fr
Language French with English translations

The Open Data Energy Networks (Open Data Réseaux Énergies or ODRÉ) portal is run by eight partners, led by the French national transmission system operator (TSO) Réseau de Transport d'Électricité (RTE). The portal was previously known as Open Data RTE. The site offers electricity system datasets under a Creative Commons CC BY 2.0 compatible license, with metadata, an RSS feed for notifying updates, and an interface for submitting questions. Re-users of information obtained from the site can also register third-party URLs (be they publications or webpages) against specific datasets.<ref name="open-data-rte-web"> RTE. "Open Data Energy Networks". Réseau de Transport d'Électricité. Paris, France. Retrieved 19 December 2017. </ref><ref name="balter-2017"> Balter, Emmanuelle (19 June 2017). La plateforme Open Data Rte [The platform Open Data RTE] (PDF) (in français). France: Centre National d'Expertise Réseaux, Réseau de Transport d'Électricité. Retrieved 19 December 2017. </ref>

The portal uses the French Government Licence Ouverte license and this is explicitly compatible with the United Kingdom Open Government Licence (OGL), the Creative Commons CC BY 2.0 license (and thereby later versions), and the Open Data Commons ODC-BY license.<ref name="licence-ouverte"> Licence Ouverte [Open license] (PDF) (in français). French Government. October 2011. Retrieved 19 December 2017. </ref>: 2 

The site hosts electricity, gas, and weather information related to France.

UK Power Networks Open Data Portal

Project Open Data Portal
Host UK Power Networks and others
Status active
Scope/type GB DNO
Data license (CC BY 4.0 compatible)
Metadata English
Website ukpowernetworks.opendatasoft.com/pages/home/
Language English

The Open Data Portal is run by UK Power Networks, a GB Distribution Network Operator (DNO), hosted on the OpenDataSoft platform. The Portal offers electricity network datasets under a Creative Commons CC BY 4.0 compatible license, with metadata, a newsfeed, and a data request form. Re-users of information obtained from the site can also register third-party URLs (be they publications or webpages) against specific datasets. A number of download formats, including GIS files, are supported: CSV, XLS, GeoJSON, KML, and SHP. The site also offers an API for automated downloads.

The portal uses the Creative Commons License and also hosts datasets from other sources which are licensed under the Open Government Licence (OGL).

The site hosts electricity datasets related to UK Power Networks' three license areas in London, the East and South East of England.

Open Power System Data

Project Open Power System Data
Host
Status active
Scope/type western European power system
Code license MIT
Data license dataset-specific 1
DOI dataset and version
Website open-power-system-data.org
Repository github.com/Open-Power-System-Data
  • 1. The project website states that data might be subject to proprietary copyright, in which case the primary data owner should be consulted. Only 2 out of 8 data sets have an open license.<ref>

"Data – Open Power System Data". Open Power System Data. Berlin, Germany. Retrieved 28 October 2016.</ref><ref> "Legal – Open Power System Data". Open Power System Data. Berlin, Germany. Retrieved 28 October 2016. </ref>

Five key data categories packed using OKI frictionless data standards

The Open Power System Data (OPSD) project seeks to characterize the German and western European power plant fleets, their associated transmission network, and related information and to make that data available to energy modelers and analysts.<ref name="open-power-system-data"> "Open power system data: a free and open data platform for power system modelling". Open Power System Data. Berlin, Germany. Retrieved 28 October 2016. </ref> The platform was originally implemented by the University of Flensburg, DIW Berlin, the Technical University of Berlin, and the energy economics consultancy Neon Neue Energieökonomik, all from Germany. The first phase of the project, from August 2015 to July 2017, was funded by the Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs and Energy (BMWi) for €490000.<ref name="fischer-2015"> Fischer, Kathrin (10 September 2015). "Energiedaten für alle – Projekt "Open Power System Data" an der EUF gestartet" [Energy data for all — project "Open Power System Data" started at the EUF]. Informationsdienst Wissenschaft (in Deutsch). Bayreuth, Germany. Retrieved 25 September 2015.</ref><ref name="freist-2015"> Freist, Roland (14 September 2015). "Offene Plattform macht Energiedaten zugänglich" [Open platform makes energy data available]. Mittelstands Wiki (in Deutsch). Bad Aibling, Germany. Retrieved 25 September 2015. </ref> The project later received funding for a second phase, from January 2018 to December 2020, with ETH Zurich replacing Flensburg University as a partner.<ref name="open-power-system-data-background"> "Background and history – Open power system data". Open Power System Data. Berlin, Germany. Retrieved 1 June 2018. </ref>

Developers collate and harmonize data from a range of government, regulatory, and industry sources throughout Europe. The website and the metadata utilize English, whereas the original material can be in any one of 24 languages. Datasets follow the emerging frictionless data package standard being developed by Open Knowledge Foundation (OKF). The website was launched on 28 October 2016. As of June 2018, the project offers the following primary packages, for Germany and other European countries:

  • details, including geolocation, of conventional power plants and renewable energy power plants
  • aggregated generation capacity by technology and country
  • hourly time series covering electrical load, day-ahead electricity spot prices, and wind and solar resources
  • a script to filter and download NASA MERRA-2 satellite weather data<ref name="merra-2" group="lower-alpha">

MERRA-2 stands for Modern-Era Retrospective analysis for Research and Applications, Version 2. The remote-sensed data is provided unencumbered by the NASA Goddard Space Flight Center research laboratory. </ref><ref name="bosilovich-etal-2016"> Bosilovich, Michael G; Lucches, Rob; Suarez, M (12 March 2016). MERRA-2: File specification — GMAO Office Note No. 9 (Version 1.1) (PDF). Greenbelt, Maryland, USA: Global Modeling and Assimilation Office (GMAO), Earth Sciences Division, NASA Goddard Space Flight Center. Retrieved 8 July 2016. </ref>

In addition, the project hosts selected contributed packages:

  • electricity demand and self-generation time series for representative south German households
  • simulated PV and wind generation capacity factor time series for Europe, generated by the Renewables.ninja project

To facilitate analysis, the data is aggregated into large structured files (in CSV format) and loaded into data packages with standardized machine-readable metadata (in JSON format).<ref name="oki-data-package"> "Data Packages". Open Knowledge International (OKI). Cambridge, United Kingdom. Retrieved 31 October 2016.</ref><ref name="oki-tabular-data-package"> "Tabular Data Package". Open Knowledge International (OSI). Cambridge, United Kingdom. Retrieved 31 October 2016. </ref> The same data is usually also provided as XLSX (Excel) and SQLite files. The datasets can be accessed in real-time using stable URLs. The Python scripts deployed for data processing are available on GitHub and carry an MIT license. The licensing conditions for the data itself depends on the source and varies in terms of openness. Previous versions of the datasets and scripts can be recovered in order to track changes or replicate earlier studies. The project also engages with energy data providers, such as transmission system operators (TSO) and ENTSO-E, to encourage them to make their data available under open licenses (for instance, Creative Commons and ODbL licenses).<ref name="osi-2016"> "Open Power System Data — An Interview with Lion Hirth and Ingmar Schlecht". Open Knowledge International (OSI). Cambridge, United Kingdom. c. 2016. Retrieved 31 October 2016. </ref>

In a 2019 publication, OPSD developers describe their design choices, implementation, and provisioning.<ref name="wiese-etal-2019"> Wiese, Frauke; Schlecht, Ingmar; Bunke, Wolf-Dieter; Gerbaulet, Clemens; Hirth, Lion; Jahn, Martin; Kunz, Friedrich; Lorenz, Casimir; Mühlenpfordt, Jonathan; Reimann, Juliane; Schill, Wolf-Peter (15 February 2019). "Open Power System Data: frictionless data for electricity system modelling" (PDF). Applied Energy. 236: 401–409. arXiv:1812.10405. doi:10.1016/j.apenergy.2018.11.097. hdl:10419/231989. ISSN 0306-2619. S2CID 56895468. Closed access icon Postprint. </ref> Information integrity remains key, with each data package having traceable provenance, curation, and packing. From October 2018, each new or revised data package is assigned a unique DOI to ensure that external references to current and prior versions remain stable.

A number of published electricity market modeling analyses are based on OPSD data.<ref name="schill-etal-2017-start-up"> Schill, Wolf-Peter; Pahle, Michael; Gambardella, Christian (3 April 2017). "Start-up costs of thermal power plants in markets with increasing shares of variable renewable generation". Nature Energy. 2 (6): 17050. Bibcode:2017NatEn...217050S. doi:10.1038/nenergy.2017.50. ISSN 2058-7546. S2CID 157104710. </ref><ref name="schill-etal-2017-prosumage"> Schill, Wolf-Peter; Zerrahn, Alexander; Kunz, Friedrich (1 June 2017). "Prosumage of solar electricity: pros, cons, and the system perspective" (PDF). Economics of Energy & Environmental Policy. 6 (1). doi:10.5547/2160-5890.6.1.wsch. hdl:10419/149900. ISSN 2160-5882. </ref><ref name="kendziorski-etal"> Kendziorski, Mario; Setje-Eilers, Mona; Kunz, Friedrich (June 2017). "Generation expansion planning under uncertainty: An application of stochastic methods to the German electricity system". 2017 14th International Conference on the European Energy Market (EEM). pp. 1–7. doi:10.1109/eem.2017.7981891. ISBN 978-1-5090-5499-2. S2CID 9492795. </ref><ref name="zerrahn-etal-2018"> Zerrahn, Alexander; Schill, Wolf-Peter; Kemfert, Claudia (1 September 2018). "On the economics of electrical storage for variable renewable energy sources". European Economic Review. 108: 259–279. arXiv:1802.07885. Bibcode:2018arXiv180207885Z. doi:10.1016/j.euroecorev.2018.07.004. ISSN 0014-2921. S2CID 3484041. Open access icon </ref>

In 2017, the Open Power System Data project won the Schleswig-Holstein Open Science Award <ref name="fischer-2017"> Fischer, Kathrin (26 January 2017). "Online-Plattform "Open Power System Data" erhält Preis für digitale Wissenschaft" [Online platform Open Power System Data receives prize for digital science]. idw — Informationsdienst Wissenshaft (in Deutsch). Bayreuth, Germany. Retrieved 15 December 2017. </ref> and the Germany Land of Ideas award.<ref name="deutschland-land-der-ideen-2017"> "Open Power System Data (OPSD): open platform for energy data". Deutschland Land der Ideen. Berlin, Germany. 2017. Retrieved 15 December 2017. </ref>

OpenEI

Main article: OpenEI
Project OpenEI
Host National Renewable Energy Laboratory
Status active
Scope/type US focus
Data license
  • CC0
  • open licenses
Website en.openei.org

Open Energy Information (OpenEI) is a collaborative website, run by the US government, providing open energy data to software developers, analysts, users, consumers, and policymakers.<ref name="openei-homepage"> "OpenEI — Energy Information, Data, and other Resources". OpenEI. Retrieved 26 September 2016.</ref><ref name="brodt-giles-2012"> Brodt-Giles, Debbie (2012). WREF 2012: OpenEI — an open energy data and information exchange for international audiences (PDF). Golden, CO, USA: National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL). Retrieved 24 September 2016. </ref> The platform is sponsored by the United States Department of Energy (DOE) and is being developed by the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL).<ref name="brodt-giles-2012"/> OpenEI launched on 9 December 2009.<ref name="garvin-2009">Garvin, Peggy (12 December 2009). "New Gateway: Open Energy Info". SLA Government Information Division. Dayton, OH, USA. Retrieved 26 September 2016.[permanent dead link]</ref> While much of its data is from US government sources, the platform is intended to be open and global in scope.

OpenEI provides two mechanisms for contributing structured information: a semantic wiki (using MediaWiki and the Semantic MediaWiki extension) for collaboratively-managed resources and a dataset upload facility for contributor-controlled resources. US government data is distributed under a CC0 public domain dedication, whereas other contributors are free to select an open data license of their choice. Users can rate data using a five-star system, based on accessibility, adaptability, usefulness, and general quality.<ref name="brodt-giles-2012"/> Individual datasets can be manually downloaded in an appropriate format, often as CSV files.<ref name="brodt-giles-2012"/> Scripts for processing data can also be shared through the site. In order to build a community around the platform, a number of forums are offered covering energy system data and related topics.<ref name="openei-homepage"/>

Most of the data on OpenEI is exposed as linked open data (LOD) (described elsewhere on this page). OpenEI also uses LOD methods to populate its definitions throughout the wiki with real-time connections to DBPedia, reegle, and Wikipedia.<ref name="brodt-giles-2012"/><ref name="bauer-and-kaltenboeck-2012"> Bauer, Florian; Kaltenböck, Martin (2012). Linked open data: the essentials: a quick start guide for decision makers (PDF). Vienna, Austria: edition mono/monochrom. ISBN 978-3-902796-05-9. Retrieved 26 September 2016. </ref>: 46–49 

OpenEI has been used to classify geothermal resources in the United States.<ref name="young-etal-2014"> Young, Katherine; Bennett, Mitchell; Atkins, Darren (25 February 2014). Geothermal exploration case studies on OpenEI (PDF). USA: National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL). Retrieved 24 September 2016. </ref> And to publicize municipal utility rates, again within the US.<ref name="scanion-20"> Scanion, Bill (7 September 2011). "Nationwide Utility Rates Now on OpenEI". Renewable Energy World. Nashua, NH, USA. Retrieved 24 September 2016. </ref>

OpenGridMap

Project OpenGridMap
Host Technical University of Munich
Status active
Scope/type electricity grid data worldwide
Code license proprietary copyright
Data license CC BY 3.0 IGO preferred
Website —
Web application URL TBA
Repository github.com/OpenGridMap

OpenGridMap employs crowdsourcing techniques to gather detailed data on electricity network components and then infer a realistic network structure using methods from statistics and graph theory. The scope of the project is worldwide and both distribution and transmission networks can be reverse engineered. The project is managed by the Chair of Business Information Systems, TUM Department of Informatics, Technical University of Munich, Munich, Germany. The project maintains a website and a Facebook page and provides an Android mobile app to help the public document electrical devices, such as transformers and substations. The bulk of the data is being made available under a Creative Commons CC BY 3.0 IGO license.<ref name="opengridmap-terms-of-use"> "OpenGridMap — Terms of use". Technical University of Munich. Retrieved 11 April 2017. Terms of use last amended 25 November 2016. </ref><ref group="lower-alpha">The IGO variant is designed for use by international agencies.</ref> The processing software is written primarily in Python and MATLAB and is hosted on GitHub.<ref name="rivera-etal-2015"> Rivera, José; Goebel, Christoph; Sardari, David; Jacobsen, Hans-Arno (2015). "OpenGridMap: An Open Platform for Inferring Power Grids with Crowdsourced Data". In Gottwalt, S; König, L; Schmeck, H (eds.). Energy Informatics. Lecture Notes in Computer Science. Vol. 9424. Cham, Switzerland: Springer International Publishing. pp. 179–191. doi:10.1007/978-3-319-25876-8_15. ISBN 978-3-319-25876-8. </ref><ref name="rivera-etal-2017"> Rivera, José; Leimhofer, Johannes; Jacobsen, Hans-Arno (March 2017). "OpenGridMap: towards automatic power grid simulation model generation from crowdsourced data". Computer Science — Research and Development. 32 (1): 13–23. doi:10.1007/s00450-016-0317-4. ISSN 1865-2042. S2CID 186382. </ref>

OpenGridMap provides a tailored GIS web application, layered on OpenStreetMap, which contributors can use to upload and edit information directly. The same database automatically stores field recordings submitted by the mobile app. Subsequent classification by experts allows normal citizens to document and photograph electrical components and have them correctly identified. The project is experimenting with the use of hobby drones to obtain better information on associated facilities, such as photovoltaic installations. Transmission line data is also sourced from and shared with OpenStreetMap. Each component record is verified by a moderator.

Once sufficient data is available, the transnet software is run to produce a likely network, using statistical correlation, Voronoi partitioning, and minimum spanning tree (MST) algorithms. The resulting network can be exported in CSV (separate files for nodes and lines), XML, and CIM formats. CIM models are well suited for translation into software-specific data formats for further analysis, including power grid simulation. Transnet also displays descriptive statistics about the resulting network for visual confirmation.<ref name="rivera-etal-2017"/>: 3–5 

The project is motivated by the need to provide datasets for high-resolution energy system models, so that energy system transitions (like the German Energiewende) can be better managed, both technically and policy-wise.<ref name="energate-messenger-2016"> "Münchner Forscher erstellen Stromnetz-Weltkarte" [Munich researchers are creating a power grid world map]. energate messenger+ (in Deutsch). Essen, Germany. 5 December 2016. Retrieved 6 April 2017. </ref> The rapid expansion of renewable generation and the anticipated uptake of electric vehicles means that electricity system models must increasingly represent distribution and transmission networks in some detail.

As of 2017, OpenGridMap techniques have been used to estimate the low voltage network in the German city of Garching and to estimate the high voltage grids in several other countries.

Power Explorer

Project Power Explorer
Host World Resources Institute
Status under development
Scope/type global power data
Code license —
Data license CC BY 4.0 preferred
Website powerexplorer.org
Repository —

The Power Explorer portal is a part of the larger Resource Watch platform, hosted by the World Resources Institute. The initial Global Power Plant Database, an open source database of the power plants globally, was released in April 2018.<ref name="wri-global-power-plant-database-2018"> "Global power plant database — Data — Version 1.0.0". World Resources Institute. Washington DC, USA. 6 April 2018. Retrieved 8 May 2018. Download page. Newer versions available via same link. </ref> As of May 2021, the portal itself is still under development.

Power Explorer is also supported by Google with various research partners, including KTH, Global Energy Observatory, Enipedia, and OPSD.

PowerGenome

Project PowerGenome
Host —
Status active
Scope/type US electricity system
Code license MIT
Data license CC BY 4.0
Website —
Repository github.com/PowerGenome
Mailing list groups.io/g/powergenome

The PowerGenome project aims to provide a coherent dataset covering the United States electricity system. PowerGenome was initially designed to service the GenX model,<ref name="jenkins-and-sepulveda-2017"> Jenkins, Jesse D; Sepulveda, Nestor A (27 November 2017). Enhanced decision support for a changing electricity landscape: the GenX configurable electricity resource capacity expansion model — An MIT Energy Initiative Working Paper — Revision 1.0 (PDF). Cambridge, Massachusetts, USA: Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Retrieved 6 April 2021. MITEI‑WP‑2017‑10. </ref> but support for other modeling frameworks is in planning.<ref name="powergenome-github"> PowerGenome. "PowerGenome/PowerGenome". GitHub. Retrieved 12 May 2021. </ref> The PowerGenome utility also pulls from upstream datasets hosted by the Public Utility Data Liberation project (PUDL) and the EIA, so those dependencies need to be met by users. Datasets are occasionally archived on Zenodo.<ref name="schivley-etal-2021"> Schivley, Greg; Welty, Ethan; Patankar, Neha (19 February 2021). "PowerGenome/PowerGenome: v0.4.1". Zenodo. Bibcode:2021zndo...4552835S. doi:10.5281/zenodo.4552835. Snapshot. </ref> A video describing the project is available.<ref name="schivley-2020"> Schivley, Greg (26 March 2020). Create capacity expansion model inputs with PowerGenome (MP4) (webcast). Open Energy Modelling Initiative (openmod). Retrieved 16 September 2020. MP4 webcast 00:10:55. </ref>

reegle

Main article: reegle
Project reegle
Host
Status inactive
Scope/type clean energy
Data license —
Website www.reegle.info

reegle is a clean energy information portal covering renewable energy, energy efficiency, and climate compatible development topics.<ref name="bauer-and-kaltenboeck-2012"/>: 41 <ref name="reegle-homepage"> "Clean Energy Info Portal — reegle". Vienna, Austria. Retrieved 27 September 2016.</ref><ref name="bauer-etal-2011"> Bauer, Florian; Recheis, Denise; Kaltenböck, Martin (27 June 2011). "Data.reegle.info – A New Key Portal for Open Energy Data" (PDF). In Hřebíček, Jiří; Schimak, Gerald; Denzer, Ralf (eds.). Environmental Software Systems. Frameworks of eEnvironment. IFIP Advances in Information and Communication Technology. Vol. 359. Berlin and Heidelberg, Germany: Springer. pp. 189–194. doi:10.1007/978-3-642-22285-6_21. ISBN 978-3-642-22284-9. </ref> reegle was launched in 2006 by REEEP and REN21 with funding from the Dutch (VROM), German (BMU), and UK (Defra) environment ministries.<ref name="reegle-partners"> "Partners — reegle". Archived from the original on 29 February 2008. Retrieved 29 September 2016. </ref> Originally released as a specialized internet search engine, reegle was relaunched in 2011 as an information portal.

reegle offers and utilizes linked open data (LOD) (described elsewhere on this page).<ref name="bauer-and-kaltenboeck-2012"/>: 43–46  Sources of data include UN and World Bank databases, as well as dedicated partners around the world. reegle maintains a comprehensive structured glossary (driven by an LOD-compliant thesaurus) of energy and climate compatible development terms to assist with the tagging of datasets. The glossary also facilitates intelligent web searches.<ref group="lower-alpha"> Alternative interfaces to the glossary, provided by the Climate Tagger project, include a tree view and an alphabetic view. </ref><ref name="bauer-etal-2011"/>: 191, 193 <ref name="reegle-glossary"> "reegle glossary". reegle — clean energy information gateway. Retrieved 26 September 2016.</ref><ref name="reeep-2015"> Turning data into knowledge (PDF). Vienna, Austria: REEEP. 2015. Retrieved 26 September 2016. </ref>

reegle offers country profiles which collate and display energy data on a per-country basis for most of the world.<ref name="reegle-country-profiles"> "Country energy profiles — Clean Energy Info Portal — reegle". Vienna, Austria. Retrieved 27 September 2016. </ref> These profiles are kept current automatically using LOD techniques.<ref name="bauer-etal-2011"/>: 193–194  As of 2021, the portal is no longer active.

Renewables.ninja

Main article: Renewables.ninja
Project Renewables, ninja
Host
Status active
Scope/type worldwide hourly PV and wind
Code license BSD-new
Data license CC BY-NC 4.0
Website www.renewables.ninja
Repository github.com/renewables-ninja

Renewables.ninja is a website that can calculate the hourly power output from solar photovoltaic installations and wind farms located anywhere in the world. The website is a joint project between the Department of Environmental Systems Science, ETH Zurich, Zürich, Switzerland and the Centre for Environmental Policy, Imperial College London, London, United Kingdom. The website went live during September 2016. The resulting time series are provided under a Creative Commons CC BY-NC 4.0 license (which is unfortunately not open data conformant) and the underlying power plant models are published using a BSD-new license. As of February 2017, only the solar model, written in Python, has been released.<ref name="renewables-ninja-website"> "Renewables.ninja". Retrieved 2 February 2017. </ref>

Screenshot showing simulated photovoltaic output for a site in northern Italy for the year 2014

The project relies on weather data derived from meteorological reanalysis models and weather satellite images. More specifically, it uses the 2016 MERRA-2 reanalysis dataset from NASA <ref name="merra-2" group="lower-alpha"></ref> and satellite images from CM-SAF SARAH.<ref name="mueller-etal-2015"> Müller, Richard; Pfeifroth, Uwe; Träger-Chatterjee, Christine; Cremer, Roswitha; Trentmann, Jörg; Hollmann, Rainer (2015). Surface solar radiation data set: heliosat (SARAH) — Edition 1. Hessen, Germany: EUMETSAT Satellite Application Facility on Climate Monitoring (CM SAF). doi:10.5676/EUM_SAF_CM/SARAH/V001. Contains datasets from 1983 to 2013. File size 3.6 TB. </ref> For locations in Europe, this weather data is further "corrected" by country so that it better fits with the output from known PV installations and windfarms. Two 2016 papers describe the methods used in detail in relation to Europe. The first covers the calculation of PV power.<ref name="pfenninger-and-staffel-2016"> Pfenninger, Stefan; Staffell, Iain (1 November 2016). "Long-term patterns of European PV output using 30 years of validated hourly reanalysis and satellite data". Energy. 114: 1251–1265. doi:10.1016/j.energy.2016.08.060. hdl:10044/1/39122. ISSN 0360-5442. Open access icon </ref> And the second covers the calculation of wind power.<ref name="staffell-and-pfenninger-2016"> Staffell, Iain; Pfenninger, Stefan (1 November 2016). "Using bias-corrected reanalysis to simulate current and future wind power output". Energy. 114: 1224–1239. doi:10.1016/j.energy.2016.08.068. hdl:20.500.11850/120087. ISSN 0360-5442. Open access icon </ref>

The website displays an interactive world map to aid the selection of a site. Users can then choose a plant type and enter some technical characteristics. As of February 2017, only year 2014 data can be served, due to technical restrictions. The results are automatically plotted and are available for download in hourly CSV format with or without the associated weather information. The site offers an API for programmatic dataset recovery using token-based authorization. Examples deploying cURL and Python are provided.

A number of studies have been undertaking using the power production datasets underpinning the website (these studies predate the launch of the website), with the bulk focusing on energy options for Great Britain.<ref name="staffel-and-green-2014"> Staffell, Iain; Green, Richard (June 2014). "How does wind farm performance decline with age?". Renewable Energy. 66: 775–786. doi:10.1016/j.renene.2013.10.041. ISSN 0960-1481. Open access icon </ref><ref name="pfenninger-and-keirstead-2015"> Pfenninger, Stefan; Keirstead, James (15 August 2015). "Renewables, nuclear, or fossil fuels? Scenarios for Great Britain's power system considering costs, emissions and energy security". Applied Energy. 152: 83–93. doi:10.1016/j.apenergy.2015.04.102. hdl:20.500.11850/105689. ISSN 0306-2619. Open access icon </ref><ref name="heuberger-etal-2016"> Heuberger, Clara F; Staffell, Iain; Shah, Nilay; Mac Dowell, Niall (2016). "Quantifying the value of CCS for the future electricity system". Energy and Environmental Science. 9 (8): 2497–2510. doi:10.1039/C6EE01120A. hdl:10044/1/34750. ISSN 1754-5692. Retrieved 2 February 2017. Open access icon </ref><ref name="macdowell-and-staffell-2016"> Mac Dowell, Niall; Staffell, Iain (May 2016). "The role of flexible CCS in the UK's future energy system". International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control. 48/2: 327–344. Bibcode:2016IJGGC..48..327M. doi:10.1016/j.ijggc.2016.01.043. ISSN 1750-5836. </ref><ref name="samsatli-etal-2016"> Samsatli, Sheila; Staffell, Iain; Samsatli, Nouri J (5 January 2016). "Optimal design and operation of integrated wind-hydrogen-electricity networks for decarbonising the domestic transport sector in Great Britain". International Journal of Hydrogen Energy. 41 (1): 447–475. doi:10.1016/j.ijhydene.2015.10.032. hdl:10044/1/27742. ISSN 0360-3199. Open access icon </ref><ref name="staffell-and-green-2016"> Staffell, Iain; Green, Richard (January 2016). "Is there still merit in the merit order stack? The impact of dynamic constraints on optimal plant mix" (PDF). IEEE Transactions on Power Systems. 31 (1): 43–53. Bibcode:2016ITPSy..31...43S. doi:10.1109/TPWRS.2015.2407613. hdl:10044/1/23805. ISSN 0885-8950. S2CID 12921210. </ref><ref name="green-etal"> Green, Richard; Pudjianto, D; Staffell, Iain; Strbac, G (2016). "Market design for long-distance trade in renewable electricity". The Energy Journal. 37 (SI2): 5–22. doi:10.5547/01956574.37.SI2.agia. hdl:10044/1/52978. Open access icon. </ref>

SMARD

Project SMARD
Host German Federal Network Agency (BNetzA)
Status active
Scope/type German, Austrian, and Luxembourg (DE/AT/LU) electricity systems
Data license
  • market data visuals and underlying time series are CC BY 4.0
Website www.smard.de
Language English and German
Plot from the SMARD site showing electricity generation in Germany in mid-December 2017

The SMARD site (pronounced "smart") serves electricity market data from Germany, Austria, and Luxembourg and also provides visual information. The electricity market plots and their underlying time series are released under a permissive CC BY 4.0 license.<ref name="bnetza-smard-tos"> BNetzA (2017). "Data use". Bundesnetzagentur. Bonn, Germany. Retrieved 22 January 2018. Terms of use for the BNetzA SMARD data portal. </ref> The site itself was launched on 3 July 2017 in German and an English translation followed shortly. The data portal is mandated under the German Energy Industry Act (Energiewirtschaftsgesetz or EnWG) section §111d, introduced as an amendment on 13 October 2016. Four table formats are offered: CSV, XLS, XML, and PDF. The maximum sampling resolution is 15 min. Market data visuals or plots can be downloaded in PDF, SVG, PNG, and JPG formats. Representative output is shown in the thumbnail (on the left), in this case mid-winter dispatch over two days for the whole of Germany. The horizontal ordering by generation type is first split into renewable and conventional generation and then based on merit. A user guide is updated as required.<ref name="bnetza-2021"> BNetzA (September 2021). SMARD.de User guide (PDF). Bonn, Germany: Bundesnetzagentur für Elektrizität, Gas, Telekommunikation, Post und Eisenbahnen (BNetzA). Retrieved 20 July 2022. </ref>

See also

Notes

<references group="lower-alpha" responsive="1"></references>

References

<references group="" responsive="0"></references>

Further information

External links

Retrieved from "https://kynnco.com:443/kynnpedia/index.php?title=Open_energy_system_databases&oldid=3426"