Turbidity

"Turbid" redirects here. For other uses, see Turbid (disambiguation).

Turbidity is the cloudiness or haziness of a fluid caused by large numbers of individual particles that are generally invisible to the naked eye, similar to smoke in air. The measurement of turbidity is a key test of both water clarity and water quality.

Fluids can contain suspended solid matter consisting of particles of many different sizes. While some suspended material will be large enough and heavy enough to settle rapidly to the bottom of the container if a liquid sample is left to stand (the settable solids), very small particles will settle only very slowly or not at all if the sample is regularly agitated or the particles are colloidal. These small solid particles cause the liquid to appear turbid.

Turbidity (or haze) is also applied to transparent solids such as glass or plastic. In plastic production, haze is defined as the percentage of light that is deflected more than 2.5° from the incoming light direction.<ref>Thermallaminatingfilms.com. Haze technical definition Archived August 22, 2015, at the Wayback Machine</ref>

Causes and effects

Turbidity in open water may be caused by growth of phytoplankton. Human activities that disturb land, such as construction, mining and agriculture, can lead to high sediment levels entering water bodies during rain storms due to storm water runoff. Areas prone to high bank erosion rates as well as urbanized areas also contribute large amounts of turbidity to nearby waters, through stormwater pollution from paved surfaces such as roads, bridges, parking lots and airports.<ref>National Management Measures to Control Nonpoint Source Pollution from Urban Areas (Report). Washington, D.C.: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). November 2005. EPA 841-B-05-004. Chapters 7-8.</ref> Some industries such as quarrying, mining and coal recovery can generate very high levels of turbidity from colloidal rock particles.

In drinking water, the higher the turbidity level, the higher the risk that people may develop gastrointestinal diseases.<ref>Mann, A.G.; Tam, C.C.; Higgins, C.D.; Lodrigues, L.L. (2007-09-21). "The association between drinking water turbidity and gastrointestinal illness: a systematic review". BMC Public Health. Springer Nature. 7 (256): 256. doi:10.1186/1471-2458-7-256. PMC 2174477. PMID 17888154.</ref> This is especially problematic for immunocompromised people, because contaminants like viruses or bacteria can become attached to the suspended solids. The suspended solids interfere with water disinfection with chlorine because the particles act as shields for viruses and bacteria. Similarly, suspended solids can protect bacteria from ultraviolet (UV) sterilization of water.

In water bodies such as lakes, rivers and reservoirs, high turbidity levels can reduce the amount of light reaching lower depths, which can inhibit growth of submerged aquatic plants and consequently affect species which are dependent on them, such as fish and shellfish. High turbidity levels can also affect the ability of fish gills to absorb dissolved oxygen. This phenomenon has been regularly observed throughout the Chesapeake Bay in the eastern United States.<ref> Stevenson, J. Court; Piper, Catherine B.; Confer, Nedra (1979). "Decline of Submerged Plants in Chesapeake Bay". Annapolis, MD: U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. Archived from the original on 2019-04-28.</ref><ref>"Sediments". Annapolis, MD: Chesapeake Bay Program. 2009-08-06. Archived from the original on 2011-09-27.</ref>

For many mangrove areas, high turbidity is needed in order to support certain species, such as to protect juvenile fish from predators. For most mangroves along the eastern coast of Australia, in particular Moreton Bay, turbidity levels as high as 600 Nephelometric Turbidity Units (NTU) are needed for proper ecosystem health.

Measurement

Turbid creek water caused by heavy rains

The measurement of turbidity is a key test of both water clarity and water quality. There are two standard units for reporting turbidity: Formazin Nephelometric Units (FNU) from ISO 7027 and Nephelometric Turbidity Units (NTU) from USEPA Method 180.1. ISO 7027 and FNU is mostly widely used in Europe, whereas NTU is mostly widely used in the U.S. The ISO 7027 provides the method in water quality for the determination of turbidity. It is used to determine the concentration of suspended particles in a sample of water by measuring the incident light scattered at right angles from the sample. The scattered light is captured by a photodiode, which produces an electronic signal that is converted to a turbidity. Open source hardware has been developed following the ISO 7027 method to measure turbidity reliably using an Arduino microcontroller and inexpensive LEDs.<ref>Wijnen, Bas; Anzalone, G.C.; Pearce, Joshua M. (2014-05-09). "Open-source mobile water quality testing platform". Journal of Water, Sanitation and Hygiene for Development. London: IWA Publishing. 4 (3): 532–537. doi:10.2166/washdev.2014.137. S2CID 111183462.</ref>

There are several practical ways of checking water quality, the most direct being some measure of attenuation (that is, reduction in strength) of light as it passes through a sample column of water.<ref name="fondriest" /> The alternatively used Jackson Candle method (units: Jackson Turbidity Unit or JTU) is essentially the inverse measure of the length of a column of water needed to completely obscure a candle flame viewed through it. The more water needed (the longer the water column), the clearer the water. Of course water alone produces some attenuation, and any substances dissolved in the water that produce color can attenuate some wavelengths. Modern instruments do not use candles, but this approach of attenuation of a light beam through a column of water should be calibrated and reported in JTUs.<ref name="fondriest" />

The propensity of particles to scatter a light beam focused on them is now considered a more meaningful measure of turbidity in water. Turbidity measured this way uses an instrument called a nephelometer with the detector set up to the side of the light beam. More light reaches the detector if there are many small particles scattering the source beam than if there are few. The units of turbidity from a calibrated nephelometer can be either NTU or FTU, depending on the standard method used. To some extent, how much light reflects for a given amount of particulates is dependent upon properties of the particles like their shape, color, and reflectivity. For this reason (and the reason that heavier particles settle quickly and do not contribute to a turbidity reading), a correlation between turbidity and total suspended solids (TSS) is somewhat unusual for each location or situation.<ref name="fondriest" >"Measuring Turbidity, TSS, and Water Clarity". Fairborn, OH: Fondriest Environmental, Inc. Retrieved 1 February 2021.</ref>

Turbidity in lakes, reservoirs, channels, and the ocean can be measured using a Secchi disk. This black and white disk is lowered into the water until it can no longer be seen; the depth (Secchi depth) is then recorded as a measure of the transparency of the water (inversely related to turbidity). The Secchi disk has the advantages of integrating turbidity over depth (where variable turbidity layers are present), being quick and easy to use, and inexpensive. It can provide a rough indication of the depth of the euphotic zone with a 3-fold division of the Secchi depth, however this cannot be used in shallow waters where the disk can still be seen on the bottom.<ref name="Myre and Shaw" />

An additional device, which may help measuring turbidity in shallow waters is the turbidity tube.<ref>Waterwatch Australia, Module 4 - physical and chemical parameters "Methods Turbidity"</ref><ref name="Myre and Shaw" >Myre, E, Shaw, R. The Turbidity Tube: Simple and Accurate Measurement of Turbidity in the Field. "The Turbidity Tube"</ref> The turbidity tube condenses water in a graded tube which allows determination of turbidity based on a contrast disk in its bottom, being analogous to the Secchi disk.

Turbidity in air, which causes solar attenuation, is used as a measure of pollution. To model the attenuation of beam irradiance, several turbidity parameters have been introduced, including the Linke turbidity factor (T_L).<ref>HelioClim (Center for Energy and Processes). Paris, France. "Linke Turbidity Factor." Archived 2011-07-23 at the Wayback Machine</ref><ref>Kasten, F. (March 1996). "The linke turbidity factor based on improved values of the integral Rayleigh optical thickness". Solar Energy. Elsevier. 56 (3): 239–244. Bibcode:1996SoEn...56..239K. doi:10.1016/0038-092X(95)00114-7..</ref>

Standards and test methods

Turbidimeters used at a water purification plant to measure turbidity (in NTU) of raw water and clear water after filtration.

Drinking water standards

Governments have set standards on the allowable turbidity in drinking water. In the United States, public water systems that use conventional or direct filtration methods must not have a turbidity higher than 1.0 NTU at the plant outlet and all samples for turbidity must be less than or equal to 0.3 NTU for at least 95 percent of the samples in any month. Systems that use filtration other than the conventional or direct filtration must follow state limits, which must include turbidity at no time exceeding 5 NTU. Many drinking water utilities strive to achieve levels as low as 0.1 NTU.<ref>"National Primary Drinking Water Regulations". EPA. 2022-01-26.</ref> The European turbidity standard is 4 NTU.<ref>"What are the drinking water standards?" (PDF). London: Drinking Water Inspectorate (UK). June 2017. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2020-11-11.</ref>

Ambient water standards

United States

The US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has published water quality criteria for turbidity.<ref>Quality Criteria for Water (PDF) (Report). EPA. 1986. EPA 440/5-86-001. (Commonly known as the "Gold Book.").</ref> These criteria are scientific assessments of the effects of turbidity, which are used by states to develop water quality standards for water bodies. (States may also publish their own criteria.) Some states have promulgated water quality standards for turbidity, including:

• Louisiana. 25, 50 or 150 NTU, or background plus 10 percent, depending on the water body.<ref>Louisiana Department of Environmental Quality. Baton Rouge, Louisiana."Surface Water Quality Standards." Louisiana Administrative Code (LAC). Title 33, Part IX, Chapter 11. August 6, 2007.</ref>
• Vermont. 10 NTU or 25 NTU, depending on water body classification.<ref>Vermont Water Resources Board. Montpelier, Vermont. "Vermont Water Quality Standards." Archived 2013-12-31 at the Wayback Machine January 25, 2006.</ref>
• Washington. 5 NTU over background (when background is 50 NTU or less), or 10 percent increase when background is over 50 NTU.<ref>Washington Department of Ecology. Olympia, Washington."Water Quality Standards for Surface Waters of the State of Washington." Washington Administrative Code (WAC). Chapter 173-201A. November 18, 1997.</ref>

Analytical methods

Published analytical test methods for turbidity include:

• ISO 7027 "Water Quality: Determination of Turbidity" <ref>International Organization for Standardization. Geneva, Switzerland.

"ISO 7027-1:2016 Water quality – Determination of turbidity – Part 1: Quantitative Methods." 2016 and "ISO 7027-2:2019 Water quality – Determination of turbidity – Part 2: Semi-quantitative methods for the assessment of transparency of waters." 2019.</ref>

• US EPA Method No. 180.1, "Turbidity"<ref>EPA. Environmental Monitoring Systems Laboratory. Cincinnati, Ohio. "Method 180.1: Determination of Turbidity by Nephelometry; Revision 2.0." August 1993.</ref>
• "Standard Methods", No. 2130B.<ref>Eaton, Andrew D.; Greenberg, Arnold E.; Rice, Eugene W.; Clesceri, Lenore S.; Franson, Mary Ann H., eds. (2005). Standard Methods For the Examination of Water and Wastewater (21 ed.). American Public Health Association. ISBN 978-0-87553-047-5. Also available on CD-ROM and online by subscription.</ref>

Treatment

Turbidity is commonly treated using a settling or filtration process, or both settling and filtration. Depending on the application, flocculants may be dosed into the water stream to increase the effectiveness of the settling or filtration process.<ref name="AWWA">Water Treatment, Grade 1. Denver, CO, USA: American Water Works Association. 2016.</ref><ref name="SARAI">Darshan Singh Sarai (2006). Water Treatment Made Simple For Operators. John Wiley.</ref> Potable water treatment and municipal wastewater plants often remove turbidity with a combination of settling tanks, granular media filtration, and clarifiers.

In-situ water treatment or direct dosing for the treatment of turbidity is common when the affected water bodies are dispersed (i.e. there are numerous water bodies spread out over a geographical area, such as small drinking water reservoirs), when the problem is not consistent (i.e. when there is turbidity in a water body only during and after the wet season) or when a low cost solution is required. In-situ treatment of turbidity involves the addition of a reagent, generally a flocculant, evenly dispensed over the surface of the body of water. The flocs then settle at the bottom of the water body where they remain or are removed when the water body is drained. This method is commonly used at coal mines and coal loading facilities where stormwater collection ponds have seasonal issues with turbidity. A number of companies offer portable treatment systems for in-situ water treatment or direct dosing of reagents.

Reagents

There are a number of chemical reagents that are available for treating turbidity. Reagents that are available for treating turbidity include aluminium sulfate or alum (Al₂(SO₄)₃·nH₂O), ferric chloride (FeCl₃), gypsum (CaSO₄·2H₂O), poly-aluminium chloride, long chain acrylamide-based polymers and numerous proprietary reagents.<ref>Earth Systems, Clear Solutions newsletter - Focus on Turbidity [1] 2003.</ref> The water chemistry must be carefully considered when chemical dosing as some reagents, such as alum, will alter the pH of the water.

The dosing process must also be considered when using reagents as the flocs may be broken apart by excessive mixing.

See also

• McFarland standards – Scale for turbidity measurement - reference for microbiological analysis
• Ocean optics
• Transparency and translucency – Property of an object or substance to transmit light with minimal scattering
• Water clarity
• Water quality

External links

• Water on the Web: "Turbidity" (University of Minnesota, Duluth and Lake Superior College)
• "Turbidity and Water" United States Geological Survey (USGS)
• USGS field manual on measuring turbidity
• Water Quality - Stormwater, Washington State